If this is a debate you enjoy, and it is certainly compelling, you will want to link to this write-up. Steel producers say steel is cleaner if you consider the entire process. Aluminum producers say their data is faulty/old. Certainly, if the low-carbon process mentioned earlier is perfected, aluminum will be favored. Production techniques such as improved soldering methods have resulted in virtually all automotive heat exchangers being made of aluminum.
For more on this story.